The ‘right to switch off’; a new era for employee engagement?
Should managers be allowed to email after hours?
There’s been a lot of talk about this lately, especially with the Labour Party’s proposed ‘right to switch off’ legislation making headlines.
This proposal is a bold move towards improving how we manage the boundary between work and personal life, and I believe it has the potential to bring about significant positive changes. However, like any policy, its success will hinge on how meaningfully and empathetically it’s implemented.
The problem is balancing flexibility and boundaries
The modern workplace is more flexible than ever, with many managers and employees working non-traditional hours.
This flexibility is often seen as a perk, allowing people to tailor their work schedules to better fit their personal lives. However, with this flexibility comes the risk of blurring the lines between work and home. When managers send emails after hours, even with the best of intentions, it can create an implicit expectation that employees should be available at all times.
This concern is not unique to the UK. Just a few days ago, on 26th August, Australia implemented its ‘Right to Disconnect’ legislation, marking a significant shift in how digital connectivity is managed in relation to personal time.
The Australian law is designed to protect employees from unreasonable out-of-hours contact, addressing issues like burnout and the mental health challenges associated with an “always-on” culture. Like the UK’s proposed law, Australia’s legislation aims to set clear boundaries, ensuring that employees can disconnect from work without fear of repercussions.
The solution is to implement the right to disconnect with empathy
Implementing a policy like this is about more than just setting rules; it’s about creating a culture of respect and understanding within the workplace.
Here’s how you could implement this policy effectively:
- Clarify expectations: Communicate clearly that employees are not obligated to respond to emails outside of working hours. This can be established through formal policies or informal team agreements, reducing the stress associated with after-hours communication.
- Use email scheduling tools: Managers can maintain their flexibility by using email scheduling tools, which allow them to send emails during their working hours but deliver them to employees during theirs. This reinforces the idea that employees are not expected to be ‘on’ after hours.
- Include clear notes in after-hours emails: When after-hours emails are necessary, include a note stating that no immediate response is expected. This small gesture can alleviate any unspoken pressure on employees and set a positive example for team communication.
- Promote open dialogue about communication preferences: Encourage managers and employees to discuss their communication preferences. Some employees might prefer to address emails as they come in, while others may choose to disconnect entirely during non-working hours. Understanding these preferences allows for a tailored approach that respects individual needs and promotes a healthier work-life balance.
Learning from international examples
Australia’s recent legislation offers valuable lessons for the UK. One of the key challenges highlighted in Australia is the need to balance global business operations with the right to disconnect.
Many companies operate across different time zones, and the legislation will require them to develop new protocols for urgent communications and establish clear guidelines on what constitutes a genuine work emergency. This is particularly relevant for UK businesses with international ties.
Moreover, the Australian approach underscores the importance of creating a results-oriented work culture. Rather than valuing constant availability, organisations should focus on outputs and achievements. This shift can lead to more thoughtful, deliberate communication during working hours and reduce the need for after-hours interactions. In turn, employees are likely to experience less stress, better mental health, and enhanced overall wellbeing.
The UK perspective: empathy and clarity are key
As the UK moves forward with its own potential right to switch off, it’s crucial to remember that the success of such legislation will depend on its implementation. Clear communication, the use of scheduling tools, and fostering open dialogue are essential steps in creating a work environment that truly respects personal time.
The proposed right to switch off is a step in the right direction, offering an opportunity to rethink how we approach work and personal life. By focusing on empathy and clarity, we can build a culture that not only respects personal time but also leads to a more engaged and productive workforce. After all, a well-rested employee is a productive one, and by respecting their right to disconnect, businesses can foster a more motivated, loyal, and engaged workforce.
Enjoyed this Deep Dive?
There's more, much more, where that came from.
Join over 300 senior HR and employee wellbeing professionals on the final Thursday of each month, where we tackle employee wellbeing challenges and break them down into practical, actionable steps, so you can get the best out of your employee experience.
When joining our Deep Dive, you'll be added to our mailing list. We will never share your personal information with anyone. Ever.
